MassMutual Class Action Trial Ends in Defense Verdict

March 02, 2018  |   Recent Posts   |     |   Comments Off on MassMutual Class Action Trial Ends in Defense Verdict

A jury in Los Angeles Superior Court found Tuesday that Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Co. (“MassMutual”) did not improperly withhold dividends from a class of hundreds of term life insurance policyholders.  The jury sided with the insurer and found that the policies in question never generated enough profit to warrant dividends under the policy agreements.

In Christina Chavez v. Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Co., after deliberations following a 12-day trial, the jury rejected named plaintiff Christina Chavez’s claims that the insurer had breached its contracts with hundreds of people who had purchased participating 20-year term life insurance, or T20G policies, from 2000 to 2004 in the Los Angeles area.

As a mutual insurance company owned by its policyholders, MassMutual pays out its excess profits to “participating” policyholders each year in the form of dividends.  Chavez filed suit in April 2010, and in her trial brief filed last month contended that as part of the language of the participating life insurance policies, the insurer was mandated to annually determine those policies’ contributions to the company’s excess profits, or “divisible surplus,” and return their fair share in a dividend.  During closing arguments, the plaintiff attorney claimed that the company had dodged its duties by refusing to actually do the math and determine if the T20G policies were entitled to dividends each year, asserting that MassMutual actually owed the class a total of $717,000 in dividends.  The jury sided with the insurer in holding the plaintiffs had failed to prove that the policies actually generated such profits.

Jennifer Keller of Keller Anderle LLP, representing MassMutual, defended the company during closing arguments by focusing on Chavez’s actuarial expert Tom Bakos, explaining to the jury that Bakos had manipulated the financial numbers to show a profit on the T20G policies, which actually had not come close to surpassing a 5 percent profit, the threshold over which dividends were payable, she said.  “The Tom Bakoses of the world can probably find any mutual life insurance policy anywhere in the world and pick it apart … and can find somewhere in there some numbers to manipulate,” she said.  Sean Commons of Sidley Austin was second chair at the trial.

“After close to a decade of protracted litigation, a California jury confirmed what MassMutual has always known: that these policies never earned, and were therefore never entitled to receive, dividends,” MassMutual spokesperson Michael McNamara said in a statement Wednesday, stating that the company was very pleased with the verdict.

NEWS RELEASE

Other Posts

  • Thank you first responders!
    April 3, 2020

    We appreciate the dedicated first responders who are helping so bravely with the COVID-19 pandemic. Keller/Anderle is pleased to provide lunches to Costa Mesa police and fire departments through Dick Church’s Restaurant. Thank you first responders!

  • Reuben Camper Cahn admitted to American College of Trial Lawyers
    March 20, 2020

    Founded in 1950, the College is composed of the best of the trial bar from the United States and Canada. Fellowship in the College is extended by invitation only. Lawyers must have a minimum of fifteen years trial experience before they can be considered for Fellowship. Membership in the College cannot exceed one percent of the total lawyer population of any state or province.

  • Government drops plans to use Costa Mesa facility as coronavirus quarantine site
    March 4, 2020

    Keller/Anderle’s successful application for a temporary restraining order led the state and federal governments to announce Friday they would abandon their plan to use the Fairview Developmental Center in Costa Mesa to quarantine coronavirus patients. 

  • Keller/Anderle obtains temporary restraining order for City of Costa Mesa in coronavirus quarantine case
    February 24, 2020

    The action was to stop a possible plan by state and federal agencies to use the Fairview Developmental Center to house and quarantine people with the coronavirus. Jennifer Keller, an attorney for the city, said Friday evening that it is hard to reconcile how Fairview could be suitable for coronavirus quarantine when it had recently been deemed unfit for a homeless shelter without extensive improvements.

  • Kay Anderle, Jesse Gessin and Chase Scolnick named to list of “Southern California Super Lawyers”
    February 13, 2020

    Keller/Anderle LLP is pleased to announce the selection of Kay Anderle, Jesse Gessin and Chase Scolnick to the 2020 edition of “Southern California Super Lawyers.”